Home
The Hockey Rodent
Rangerland
Messageboard
Birdcage
Archives
Buy Hockeybird Stuff !

RSS Feed

Podcast




Report Card: CAR 1 @ NYR 4
Thursday - October 30, 2003


10/30/03 1
2
3
OT
F

0 1 0
1

1 2 1
4

Goalie
GA/SH
Grade
Comments
Mike Dunham
#30, G
1/30 A- Needed to have a good 1st period and he did. Nothing highlight reel but looked sharp, especially with directing his rebounds away from traffic. See Poti's column for a longer description of Carolina's goal, one which I don't know if I should discredit Dunham on or not. Later in the 2nd made the save of the game with a stacked pad stop on a breaking 'Cane, score still 1-1 at the time. Could've been an entirely different game if Dunham didn't pull that one out. Also made a few very nice ones in the 3rd to keep the 'Canes down. As steady as you could ask for tonight. Named 3rd Star.
Jussi Markkanen
#40, G
0/0

(DNP)
Defenseman
Ice Time
Grade
Comments
Greg de Vries
#4, LD
16:24 C- Okay, after a good few opening games he quieted down, now he's even starting to play poorly at times. Carolina's first goal de Vries seemed to be left behind in the corner after a puck battle. 2nd period, bad pass just outside his blueline caused a mini-break that Dunham had to make a great save on. Lost the puck along the boards again in the 2nd which led to a good Carolina chance.
Tom Poti
#3, RD
21:56 B I need to see the replay of Carolina's first goal a few more times because I can't really tell what happened. Poti was there, swiped at the puck... but... I don't know. Did it ever get to O'Neill in front of the net? Did Poti flub the clearing attempt? I can't tell. Am I the only one who thinks his defense has been much, much better this season? In fact, he's been downright GOOD defensively. The offense has been pretty absent, though.
Vladimir Malakhov
#23, LD
20:13 B+ He was having a pretty brutal 1st period with several flubs until he made the play that caused Carter's SH goal. Malakhov got the puck and patiently glided towards the goalie waiting for Carter to get open, he did, Malakhov hit him with the cross-crease pass for the tap-in. Nice play. Him and Bobo had a very productive night, each ending up with a +3.
Boris Mironov
#29, RD
18:41 B Boris has been awfully quiet this season. Solid, but quiet. I miss the hits. +3.
Darius Kasparaitis
#6, LD
15:46 B- Missed a hip check along the blueline boards which sent Carolina on a 2-on-1 that Bouchard had to cover up. He's still the weak link on this defense, but he's not playing that badly.
Joel Bouchard
#74, RD
21:02 B+ Very nice play 1st period sliding to block a 2-on-1 centering pass. Covered up for a few more mistakes, too. Really has settled down into the solid, dependable Bouchard we saw last season.
Forward
Ice Time
Grade
Comments
Petr Nedved
#93, C
24:39 B+ Very tough 1st period. One time had the puck over a sprawled out Weeks and just shot it right over the top with the upper 3/4ths of the net open. Then with 10 seconds left and Nedved with the space to wind up for a wrister, missed the net completely. Redeemed himself in the 2nd period by scoring on the PP - shot into the goalie but followed up his shot and put the rebound in. Led the team with 5 shots and logged a whopping 24:39, a hell of a lot of ice time for a forward.
Jan Hlavac
#37, LW
13:20 C+ Not as noticable or aggressive as he's usually been.
Alexei Kovalev
#27, RW
23:18 B+ Really looking good right now. Seems confident with the puck to the point where almost no one can take it away from him. Getting lots of shots off, good passing, no major mistakes... I'll take a disciplined 60 point Kovalev over an error-prone 80 point one. 4 shots.
Bobby Holik
#16, C
21:35 B Fiesty game. Nothing particular really stood out but usually seemed to have a glove in the face or a stick in the ribs. Was matched against Brind'Amour most of the night and did a very nice job at it. The whole line did, really.
Martin Rucinsky
#26, LW
17:29 B- Drew at least one power play, perhaps two. Skated and played well enough, though not one of the more prominent Rangers.
Anson Carter
#22, RW
19:10 B+ That's why I like Carter. He FINALLY scores in the 1st period, only his second goal as a Ranger in 20-some games and Carter was so thrilled he punched the air hard enough to knock all it's teeth out. You've gotta like that. Slowly, he's getting better every game. A goal, +2 and 2 shots is a nice night.
Mark Messier
#11, C
18:48 B A replay showed him grabbing his neck in the 1st period. Oh good God, not the neck AGAIN! At least he still has the smarts, as demonstrated on his great screen during the Rangers second goal. Also connected in the 3rd on a great pass from Lundmark, and, hey, Messier didn't flub it! Honestly it's not that he's playing that badly, his strength and stamina limitations are just very frustrating. He would have about 5 goals and 10 points by now with a 10-year younger body.
Chris Simon
#17, LW
3:35 B Got nailed with a totally bogus boarding call and ejection in the 1st period. Clearly hit Cole from the side and with elbows and forearms down. Sigh. However, this does make Simon, who was already leading the league with 47 PIM's, way out in front now with 62. Rock on with your bad ass self, Mr. Simon!
Matthew Barnaby
#36, RW
11:05 B Well, he did draw a 4min. power play by taking a nasty stick to the nose... and that's all he did tonight. JD was raving about Barnaby's forechecking on the Rangers fourth goal, but honestly all I saw was Barnaby skate into the corner and fall down. Maybe I missed something.(?)

LATE UPDATE: The pass on goal #4 I gave Lundmark credit for was actually Barnaby's pass, and a beautiful one it was. Barnaby's grade moves up from a C+ to a B.
Jamie Lundmark
#21, C
16:40 A-

That's the way to do it. Never mind your draft position or prior history, you're guaranteed nothing when you come to the NHL and have to make a name for yourself all over again. For one of the few nights in his Ranger career, Lundmark seemed to understand that tonight. He skated hard, made some hits, kept the play moving and even scored a goal by smartly putting it on net from a bad angle when there were no other options. Put the game away in the 3rd by coming out of the corner with the puck and making a beautiful pass to a streaking Messier. EXCELLENT game. Finally, for the first time in what seems like forever I have some genuine great things to say about Lundmark tonight. Deservedly first star of the game.

Dan Lacouture
#39, LW
2:56 C If this keeps up I'm going to start renting out Lacouture's column for classified ads like I used to do with Sylvain Lefebvre's column. So if you have a job you need filled, want to sell your fish tank or are looking for a date, keep this space in mind. Low rates.

...And then he gets in a meaningless fight at the end of the game just so I have to write something! He must've sensed his column was going up for grabs. Very sneaky, Lacouture. Good for him, though. He knows his status on this team is very tenuous and did something late with a 4-1 lead to be noticed.
Mike Siklenka
#18, RW
2:22 C Three shifts. Fell down on one of them. YEAH!

COACHING STAFF:
x .

1st PERIOD:
B- A pretty ugly period salvaged by a late Carter goal. Rangers controlled the play for the first 5-7 minutes but it was mostly Carolina after that. The power play looked even worse. In fact, they had a 4min. PP without a single shot! They also took two minors and a major in the period, all were touchy calls, though. Carolina had the shots by 11-5! Rangers really earned about a "D+" this period, but hell, when you come out of the period with a 1-0 lead...
2nd PERIOD:
B+ Mirror image of the 1st, except for the goal scoring. Pretty badly outplayed in the beginning of the period but then dominated the final 12-15 minutes. And, hey, THEY SCORED ON THE POWER PLAY! I'll take the goal yet shed a tear for the record of not scoring a PP goal from the beginning of the season that the Rangers were so close to. Shots were 11-6 Rangers.
3rd PERIOD:
B Strong period. Carolina had maybe two or three serious scoring chances while the Rangers seemed to enjoy their multiple goal lead and tried to pour it on. Shots were 11-8 for the 'Canes, but it really didn't look like it.
OVERALL:
B+

Let's look at some positives: Last season they also started out 2-2-2, lost their next game and only got back to .500 for ONE night the rest of the season. This time they got right back to even the very next game. They also just completed their longest homestand of the season with what was essentially a 4-2 record (3-1-2), and you can't hope for much better than a .667 home winning percentage. .667 at home, .500 on the road and you're  not only in the playoffs easily, but challenging for the top spot. So, all in all, as good a homestand as we could've reasonably wanted, ESPECIALLY considering Lindros missed 3 of those games and Leetch all of them.


As for this game in particular, the Rangers really got lucky in the 1st period but picked it up about halfway through the game and carried the play the rest of the way. The solid defense is still there - few mistakes and shots (and bodies) are being kept to the outside - while finally the offense seems to be coming around. Actually, though, I'm not sure how much better they played tonight compared to Tuesday night against the Ducks, if they played any better at all. The only difference was Dunham was sharper and the breaks went the Rangers way this time.

Scratches:

Pavel Bure (knee - IR)
Eric Lindros (uh, chest - IR)
Brian Leetch (ankle - IR)

Dale Purinton (healthy)
Pascal Rheaume (knee)
Chad Wiseman (healthy)
created by:

Pete Rocha, © 2003. procha@optonline.net



Discuss the card here
Posted by pete at October 30, 2003 09:44 PM
eMail this entry!
Comments
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


Comments:






Hockeybird Store !


 
Web Hockeybird.com