Home
The Hockey Rodent
Rangerland
Messageboard
Birdcage
Archives
Buy Hockeybird Stuff !

RSS Feed

Podcast




Report Card: NYR 4 @ NYI 2
Thursday - December 04, 2003


12/04/03 1
2
3
OT
F

0 3 1
4

0 0 2
2

Goalie
GA/SH
Grade
Comments
Mike Dunham
#30, G
2/39 B+ Very sharp 1st period, even if he didn't have to make any edge of your seat saves. Controlled his rebounds, always seemed to be in position and found the puck through traffic. Hardly had any work in the 2nd until a fantastic save late where he dove from right to left, just getting his arm out in time to stop an Islander wraparound. He was inundated with work in the 3rd, and neither goal can I fault Dunham on since it was a shooting gallery and something was bound to go in at some point. Definitely his best game since the groin problems. The only thing that's keeping me from the A- is despite the 39 shots, the defense was fantastic and he really didn't face any spectacular scoring chances until that wraparound in the 2nd and the flood of shots in the 3rd.
Jussi Markkanen
#40, G
0/0

(DNP)
Defenseman
Ice Time
Grade
Comments
Brian Leetch
#2, LD
23:50 A+ You've got to love Leetch in big games. Even in those recent years where his play fell off he still showed up for the big games and he showed up tonight. Both of his goals weren't on plays Leetch necessarily made himself, but both times he was perfectly accurate with the wrist shot. Great game in the defensive end as well, like on the Rangers fourth goal where he won the puck from two Islanders and sent the Rangers up ice. His best of the season by a mile. Also led the team with 4 shots.
Greg de Vries
#4, RD
17:34 A- Every defenseman is getting an A- or better tonight and de Vries is no exception. Tough around his net, no noticable mistakes, can't ask for much more.
Vladimir Malakhov
#23, LD
18:09 A- Phenomenal pass to Carter streaking in near the blue line, hit him right in stride and right on the tape for Carter's breakaway goal. Played a hard game and seemed to take a beating himself as well. I have to admit, when it looked like Malakhov was injured in the 2nd period I was honestly nervous about what it would mean to the Rangers defense in both this game and in future games. How far he's come since last season.
Boris Mironov
#29, RD
17:17 A- Very strong 1st period, rock solid in his own end and was one of the few Rangers hitting during the early stretch when it was all Islanders. Wasn't a slouch in the final two periods, either. Just like the other five of 'em, great game tonight.
Tom Poti
#3, LD
20:39 A- Drew a penalty by taking a swat to the face, an important penalty seeing that the Isles came out on fire and Lundmark just took a hooking call 30 seconds earlier. Easily one of his best games season as he was tenacious on his checks all night long and won most of his board battles. Him and Kasparaitis were so good tonight that it seemed Sather was using them as the "clutch pair" during key moments in the 3rd.
Darius Kasparaitis
#6, RD
18:01 A Almost certainly his best game of the season, too. Never once looked out of position, no noticable mistakes and played hard and mean for the entire 60 minutes. Worth every penny of his $4.5 million on nights like tonight.
Forward
Ice Time
Grade
Comments
Bobby Holik
#16, C
20:55 A- Peca looked to wreck Holik with a big open ice hit, and he actually did get off a good one but it was Peca who remained on the ice for the next 60 seconds. The Isles' captain should make a note to stick to his weight class from now on. Played a tough game all night capped off by his beautiful play late in the 3rd with him and Rucinsky on a 2-on-1, waited until almost the last second, freezing DiPietro to the spot and sliding the pass between an Islander's legs for Martin to shoot it in the wide open net.
Martin Rucinsky
#26, LW
19:36 B Had a partial breakaway last in the 1st, hooked off the play but managed to get the puck somewhere on net, anyway. Scored late in the 3rd on his only shot of the game, all due to Holik's nice play which left Rucinsky with a wide open net.
Alexei Kovalev
#27, RW
24:29 B Was okay. Not involved in the scoring except for a secondary assist, but had a pretty good game on the PP point and was solid at both ends. Led the team in overall ice time as well as PK time.
Petr Nedved
#93, C
21:17 B Quite a good game. The scoring won't always be there but at least when he plays hard like tonight he's not a drag on the roster. Particularly good during the Islanders 5-on-3 PP in the 3rd. Very tenacious tonight, nothing to criticize.
Jan Hlavac
#37, LW
17:41 B- Seemed to get banged around a lot. A LOT. Give him credit, though, when the enormous Mongo (Cairns) came barreling at him at the end of the 2nd, Hlavac noticed at the last second and threw a shoulder and gave it to Mongo just as good as he took it.
Anson Carter
#22, RW
15:59 B+ Just when I was thinking Carter was having something of a "blah" game, Malakhov hits a streaking Carter who quickly put 10 feet on the defensemen and snapped a lightning quick shot through DiPietro's 5-hole. That's why you've got to keep Carter in the lineup, he may still be struggling to find himself as a Ranger but he has the natural talent to just pick it up on a few shifts and make a difference in the game, and his turned out to be the game winner. Played a strong final two periods, taking hits and doing the little things necessary to get the puck out of trouble.
Eric Lindros
#88, C
17:26 B Gorgeous, gorgeous fake-shot-pass off the side boards to Leetch streaking in from the point for the Rangers first. Highlight reel play. Strong game, both took and gave a good amount of hits.
Chris Simon
#17, LW
13:49 B I'll use Simon's column to talk about how dominating this line looked at times tonight, particularly on the Rangers opening goal where they forechecked and won every single board battle while holding the puck in for what must've been 60 seconds before Lindros hit Leetch on that great pass. As for Simon's game, he was certainly involved and played a good game, though I have to say I'm disappointed there was no heavyweight bout between Simon and Mongo, and Mongo was willing.
Matthew Barnaby
#36, RW
12:51 A+ During a 2nd period interview Stan Fischler tells Barnaby, "Islander fans were telling me they hate you," to which Barnaby responds without the slightest hint of a smirk or smile on his face, "Well, good, I hate the Islander fans too so we're on the same page there." I'M GIVING HIM AN A+ JUST FOR SAYING THAT! It's not a total stretch, either, as Barnaby was one of the most invloved Rangers all night long - yapping, hitting, just being a royal pain in the ass - the type of player who's worth his weight in gold in games like this.
Jamie Lundmark
#21, C
2:34 x

Islanders came out flying early, thoroughly outplaying the Rangers, Lundmark takes a dumb hooking penalty 3 minutes in. Later in the 1st made a nice rush wide around the Isles' defenseman and tried to time a shot with Ortmeyer crashing the net. During what I think was his only shift of the 2nd, Peca came flying at Lundmark from about 20 feet and they met leg-to-leg, giving Peca a major and a game and sent Jamie limping to the dressing room.

Richard Scott
#13, LW
1:41 x Made a beeline to Cairns in the 1st and got into a wild, swinging fight that Scott lost by about 10-8 if you're scoring at home. However, I'll always take the tradeoff of a 4th line winger taking a defenseman off for 5 minutes. Scott took it pretty good, good enough to where he was woozy after the fight and never returned.
Jed Ortmeyer
#41, RW
4:36 B Nice helmet popping hit in the 1st on Sven Butensc... Butensh... some guy on the Isles named Sven. Not much to talk about in four and a half minutes.

COACHING STAFF:
x Nothing much to talk about here, although whatever he said to them during the 3rd period timeout must've been pretty good as the Rangers turned their game around 180 degrees from that point.

1st PERIOD:
B- A case of weathering the storm? The Islanders came out the much quicker and stronger team, finishing their checks all over the ice, but after trading a few power plays the game settled down and the Rangers had the better scoring chances even though the Isles owned the shot advantage by a count of 11-6. If the game continues like this I don't like the Rangers chances.
2nd PERIOD:
A+ Fantastic period by the Rangers. Some of it came off the questionable 5 minute major to Peca, but however it happened the Rangers were in the Islanders end and in DiPietro's crease for what seemed like the entire period. Islanders actually owned the shots 9-8 but only one of those 9 were an actual scoring chance while the Rangers must've had eight of them. One of their better periods of the season.
3rd PERIOD:
D ALLLLL Islanders for the first 13 minutes until their second goal and Sather called the time out. Okay, the Rangers have a 3 goal lead and don't need to press, but this is ridiculous. Shots in the period? Are you ready for this? NINETEEN TO TWO! I know, I know, plenty of people out there will be demanding perfection and say 3rd periods like this just can't happen, and they shouldn't, but they do. They happen to the best of teams. Hey, they scored a goal when they needed it and won the game so let's just forget about this period for now.
OVERALL:
A-

Hmm. Well, the Rangers were slightly outplayed in the 1st period, HEAVILY outplayed in the 3rd period, but they did dominate the 2nd, picked up their game just enough in the 1st and 3rd to stave off disaster and it's a VERY important 4-2 win. How big? I like to look at the standings in terms of teams positions relative to the .500 mark. If the Isles won tonight, they would've improved to two under . 500 and the Rangers fall to one under .500, putting the Isles "one game" behind the Rangers. But with the Rangers winning, improving to one over .500 and the Isles falling to four under .500, I look at that as the Isles now being "five games" behind the Rangers. The difference between one game behind and five games behind, how big is that?! Maybe my little system here doesn't make much sense, but I'm sick of typing tonight. Let's just say it was a big win and I'll explain this further some other time.

Scratches:

Joel Bouchard (healthy)
Pavel Bure (knee - IR)
Dan Lacouture (shoulder)
Mark Messier (charley horse)
Dale Purinton (healthy)
Pascal Rheaume (knee - IR)
created by:

Pete Rocha, © 2003. procha@optonline.net



Discuss the card here
Posted by pete at December 04, 2003 10:09 PM
eMail this entry!
Comments
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


Comments:






Hockeybird Store !

Toby the Great and Other Stories

NHL Tickets
NY Rangers Tickets
New Jersey Devils Tickets

 

 
Web Hockeybird.com